Skip to content

What Gets Reddit and X Replies Removed: The 2026 Data

By Sayan De · · 11 min read

Cover reading: What gets replies removed on Reddit and X, measured. Removal rates, timing and links from the 2026 datasets

Last checked November 22, 2026. We read the Strandline, Ownfeed, WillItStay and Reddit transparency report pages directly. X's developer forum and Reddit's Help pages block automated readers, so for X we cite press coverage of X's announcement, and we do not quote either platform's help pages here. Where a number comes from one dataset, the text says which.

Most replies that marketers lose on Reddit are not lost to bans. A moderator or one of Reddit's filters removes them, often within a day or two, and nobody tells you. How often that happens depends on who is posting and where. One Reddit marketing service lost 54.2% of 10,752 brand-mention comments within about a week. A separate sample from founder and marketing subreddits found 23.2% of self-promotional comments removed. For ordinary posts across 108 sampled subreddits, the median share removed within 18 hours was 3%.

This page puts those numbers side by side, says what each one can and cannot tell you, and sets out what we think follows from them. It is written for founders who reply to strangers on Reddit and X by hand or with a drafting tool. For the rules we use, see how to reply on Reddit without getting shadowbanned and how to reply on X without getting flagged as spam.

Key Takeaways

  • One Reddit marketing service had 54.2% of 10,752 brand-mention comments removed within about a week. 47.1% of those removals happened on the day the comment was posted (Strandline, July to September 2026).
  • A separate sample of 3,769 comments from 12 startup and marketing subreddits found 23.2% of self-promotional comments removed, against 16.0% of ordinary ones (Ownfeed, March to July 2026). The two samples measure different things, so do not average them.
  • Ordinary comments with a link were removed 33.9% of the time, against 13.8% without one: 2.46 times as often. The promotional sample was too small to say the same.
  • In Reddit's own report, moderators made 40% of all removals, and 79.7% of those were automated. Each community's rules and filters decide most of what gets removed.
  • On X, API replies have needed the original author to mention or quote you since February 23, 2026. We found no public dataset of X reply removal rates.

The Reddit numbers, and why they disagree

Two independent measurements of marketing comments on Reddit landed far apart. Both are real, and neither is Reddit-wide.

Strandline Ownfeed
What was measured Brand-mention comments placed by one Reddit marketing service Comments in 12 startup and marketing subreddits, split into self-promotional and ordinary
Sample 10,752 comments, 3,014 subreddits, written for 80 brands 3,769 readable comments from 4,700 collected
Period July 16 to September 16, 2026 Comments posted March 15 to July 25, 2026
Result 54.2% removed within about a week 23.2% of self-promotional comments removed, 16.0% of ordinary ones
Main caveat One service's contractors, placing comments across thousands of subreddits Ownfeed's own filter labeled comments "self-promotional", and about a quarter of the ones it labeled were not

The gap is more than two to one, and the designs explain a lot of it. Strandline tracked a paid service dropping brand mentions into 3,014 subreddits, 1,728 of which received a single comment. Ownfeed looked at the newest comments in 12 startup and marketing subreddits. Strandline also notes that the service moves future comments away from subreddits where earlier ones were removed, which would, if anything, lower its observed rate.

Our reading is that a founder replying by hand, in threads where the product is relevant, sits somewhere between the two. Neither dataset measures that case, so we cannot say where. Use the range to calibrate your expectations, not to forecast your own rate.

Within Strandline's sample, the subreddit mattered. Among the 54 subreddits that received 30 or more comments, removal rates ran from 34.2% to 64.1%, around a pooled rate of 50.3%.

Removal is fast, so check early

Strandline checked each comment on the afternoon it was posted and then nightly. Of all 10,752 comments, 25.5% were already gone at the first check. Of the 5,824 comments that were eventually removed:

  • 47.1% were found on the day of posting
  • 63.7% had been found by the end of the second day
  • 94.0% had been found by the fifth night

A comment that was still live that afternoon was not safe: 28.6% of all comments were removed after the first check. Nothing is shown to the person who wrote the comment, so on Reddit a removed comment looks fine from your own account. If you only look at it once, you will count a removed comment as a success.

Ownfeed split its 3,769 readable comments four ways:

Comment type Comments Removed
Ordinary, with a link 404 33.9%
Ordinary, no link 3,214 13.8%
Self-promotional, with a link 43 27.9%
Self-promotional, no link 108 21.3%

For ordinary comments, a link meant removal 2.46 times as often (95% interval 2.09 to 2.89). Comparing within each subreddit and combining gave 2.37, so the link effect is not just a mix of different subreddits. For self-promotional comments the gap, 27.9% against 21.3%, rests on 43 and 108 comments and has a wide margin. It points the same way, but we would not rely on it.

One more number from the same data: 34 of the 35 removed self-promotional comments in the readable sample were removed by moderators or Reddit, not deleted by the author.

One week in September moved almost every subreddit

Strandline's weekly rate was steady until early September. For comments posted in the week starting September 3, removal rose to 80.3% (946 comments), and 84.3% (724 comments) the week after, up from a range of 42.1% to 52.7% in earlier weeks. Strandline reports that it rose in 40 of 42 subreddits at once.

The data cannot say why. Reddit may have tightened a filter. It may also have acted on the accounts this one service was using. For anyone relying on a past removal rate, the lesson is the same: the rate is not fixed, and it can move for every community in the same week.

Ordinary posts are removed far less

WillItStay publishes a live sample of removals. When we read the page on November 22, it showed a 3% median share of new posts removed within 18 hours across 108 sampled subreddits, with 25% in the strictest one, based on 33,471 posts. Their figures update, so yours may differ. These are posts, not comments, and a different design, so treat the comparison as context and not as a controlled test.

WillItStay also says the removals it samples are almost all per-post filtering, not shadowbans, which is why a clean account check does not mean your posts are safe.

What Reddit publishes about removals

Reddit's transparency report for January to June 2026 gives the platform-wide picture:

  • Admins removed 55,360,082 posts and comments, and the majority of admin removals were for spam (85.8%).
  • Moderators accounted for 40% of all content removed, and 79.7% of those removals were handled by automated systems such as AutoModerator or Reddit-provided safety filters.
  • Appeals do succeed: 32.8% of content-level appeals and 28.4% of account-level appeals were granted.

Reddit describes AutoModerator as a customizable tool that each community sets up, so in our reading a subreddit's own rules and filters decide most moderator removals. Reddit also says moderator removals can be for reasons such as being off-topic or badly formatted, not only for harm.

What X has published, and what it has not

On February 23, 2026, X restricted replies sent through its API (POST /2/tweets). Developers can post such a reply only when the original author mentions the replying account or quotes one of its posts. The rule applies to the Free, Basic, Pro and Pay-Per-Use tiers. Enterprise customers and Public Utility apps are exempt, and automated main posts (not replies) were unchanged (PiunikaWeb).

X's then head of product said on April 9, 2026 that X was identifying and suspending 208 bots per minute, and on July 24, 2026 that it had removed 42,000 accounts automating replies with chatbots (summary at TrustAudience). Those are statements from one executive, reported second-hand. X published no detection method and no rates for how often replies from real accounts are folded or hidden.

We looked for an X equivalent of the Reddit datasets and did not find one. Anyone quoting an X removal rate without a named sample and method has nothing you can check.

What follows from the data

These five points are our reading of the numbers above, not findings from the datasets themselves.

  1. Check every reply more than once. Most Reddit removals in Strandline's data showed up within two days, and a few trickled in until the fifth night. Look at each reply logged out about an hour after posting, again the next day, and again in a few days.
  2. Leave the link out unless the thread asks for one. The link effect is clearest for ordinary comments (2.46 times), and the promotional sample points the same way.
  3. Read the subreddit's rules and filters first. With 79.7% of moderator removals automated and rates ranging from 34.2% to 64.1% across the busiest subreddits in one sample, the community matters more than the wording of your comment.
  4. Do not treat an account check as the answer. A clean Reddit account check tells you the profile is visible. It cannot see whether a particular comment was filtered.
  5. Distrust numbers with no method. Higher removal and ban rates circulate in marketing posts. If a figure names no sample size, period or method, there is nothing to check it against.

What this data cannot tell you

  • Account age, karma and warm-up. Neither dataset isolates them, so we cannot say how much an established account helps.
  • A person replying by hand. Strandline measures a paid service, and Ownfeed's labels are approximate. Neither is a founder answering a real question.
  • Why removals happen. Both datasets record that a comment disappeared, not whether a moderator, AutoModerator or a Reddit filter removed it.
  • X reply removals. There is no public sample we could find.

What SocialGTM does about it

SocialGTM runs your go-to-market on social: it finds public posts where someone is asking for what you build and drafts replies for you to approve. On Reddit and X it works this way:

  • You press Post. Approving a reply copies it and opens the thread (Reddit) or opens x.com with the reply filled in (X). SocialGTM does not post for you.
  • It looks for each reply after you post it. On Reddit, about an hour later; if a filter or moderator removed the reply, it is marked "Hidden on Reddit". On X, it finds your replies even when search hides them and marks a folded one.
  • It applies pacing limits, holds a reply when it would break your account's limits, and shows the reason on the card. On Reddit it also blocks link shorteners.

None of the numbers above are SocialGTM's own. They come from the sources listed below.

Frequently asked questions

In Ownfeed's sample, ordinary comments with a link were removed 33.9% of the time against 13.8% without, which is 2.46 times as often. For self-promotional comments the figures were 27.9% against 21.3%, from 43 and 108 comments, which is too few to rely on.

How soon after posting is a Reddit comment removed?

In Strandline's data, 25.5% of comments were gone by the first check, the same afternoon. 63.7% of all removals had been found by the end of the second day and 94.0% by the fifth night.

Does a clean shadowban check mean my comments are visible?

No. WillItStay says the removals it samples are almost all per-post filtering, not shadowbans. A Reddit account check shows whether your profile is visible. To see whether a comment is visible, view it logged out.

Is there a safe number of replies per day?

Neither dataset measures volume, so they cannot give one. Our posts on Reddit and X explain how we pace replies by account age and why we start low.

Is there an X equivalent of these numbers?

We did not find a public dataset of X reply removal rates. X's published statements describe bot removals, not how often real accounts' replies are folded or hidden. Our X account check reads a public profile; it cannot see individual replies either.

Sources

Sayan De builds SocialGTM, which runs your go-to-market on social: it finds public posts on X, Reddit and other networks and drafts replies for you to approve. This page compares datasets other people published, so weigh our reading of them accordingly. We did not run these measurements, and each is linked above so you can check it. More about SocialGTM, or contact the author.