SocialGTM vs ReplyGuy: a ReplyGuy alternative
Both tools find posts worth answering and draft a reply. Here is how they differ on price, platforms and whose account posts. This compares the product at replyguy.com, not the "reply guy" slang or the X reply tool with the same name at replyguy.appendment.com. What we say about ReplyGuy comes from its website, checked November 2026.
What each costs a month
Swipe sideways to see every column.
| Replies a month | SocialGTM | ReplyGuy | SocialGTM costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| 33 | $19Starter + 25 extra | $49Pro | 2x less |
| 100 | $39Starter + 75 extra | $99Business | 2x less |
| 333 | $99Scale | $199Enterprise | 2x less |
ReplyGuy prices are from its website, checked November 2026. ReplyGuy charges credits for posted replies and SocialGTM counts every reply it writes, including ones you reject. Each row is a ReplyGuy plan at full size. A ReplyGuy reply is posted and verified, and a SocialGTM reply is a draft you approve. ReplyGuy plans list auto-replies and start with a 3-day free trial.
What one reply costs
Swipe sideways to see every column.
| Plan | A month | Replies | Per reply |
|---|---|---|---|
| SocialGTM Starter | $9 | 25 | $0.36 |
| SocialGTM Growth | $49 | 150 | $0.33 |
| SocialGTM Scale | $99 | 400 | $0.25 |
| ReplyGuy Pro | $49 | 33 | $1.48 |
| ReplyGuy Business | $99 | 100 | $0.99 |
| ReplyGuy Enterprise | $199 | 333 | $0.60 |
| ReplyGuy Agency | $499 | 1,666 | $0.30 |
ReplyGuy sells credits, and a posted reply costs 3. Its 100, 300, 1,000 and 5,000 credit plans buy 33, 100, 333 and 1,666 posted replies a month, rounded down, if you spend credits on nothing else. A comment it finds for you costs 1 credit.
Side by side
Swipe sideways to see every column.
| Feature | SocialGTM | ReplyGuy |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | X, Reddit, Hacker News, Bluesky and LinkedIn | Reddit, X and LinkedIn |
| What you pay for | Each reply written, including ones you reject | Credits: 3 for a reply posted and verified, 1 for a comment it finds |
| Price per reply, by plan | $0.36 / $0.33 / $0.25 | $1.48 / $0.99 / $0.60 / $0.30 |
| Cheapest plan | $9 a month | $49 a month |
| Biggest monthly plan | 400 replies | 1,666 replies |
| Free trial | No | 3 days |
| Tracked keywords, by plan | 50 / 200 / 500 | 5 / 25 / 100 / 1,000 |
| Posting on Reddit | From your own account, after you approve | Its FAQ says from purchased accounts it gives you. Its how-it-works page says you publish manually |
| Posting on X | You press Post on x.com, after you approve | Its FAQ says you edit and post. Its how-it-works page says auto-replies, which you can turn off |
| Automatic replies | No. You approve every reply | Listed on every plan |
| Who the replies are for | Any job: personal, leads, community, support | Finding customers for your product |
| Contract | Month to month | Monthly or yearly |
Where ReplyGuy is ahead
- A free trial. 3 days. SocialGTM has none.
- Automatic replies. Its plans list auto-replies, which can post without you. SocialGTM waits for your approval every time.
- A bigger plan. 1,666 replies a month on Agency for $499, at $0.30 a reply. SocialGTM's biggest plan is 400 replies. Reaching 1,666 with extra replies would cost $609.
Where SocialGTM is ahead
- Price. More replies at the same price: 150 for $49 against 33 for $49, 400 for $99 against 100 for $99.
- Your own accounts. Replies go out from your account, after you approve them. ReplyGuy's FAQ says its Reddit replies come from purchased accounts. We explain how we post in why you post each reply yourself.
- More platforms. X, Reddit, Hacker News, Bluesky and LinkedIn, where ReplyGuy covers Reddit, X and LinkedIn.
- More than lead finding. Build an agent for a personal account, a community or a support desk as well as for leads. Drafts learn your voice from the edits you make.
Which to pick
Pick ReplyGuy if you want replies posted without you or need more than 400 a month on one plan. Pick SocialGTM if a lower price per reply matters most, you want every reply to come from your own account, or you use Bluesky or Hacker News.
Questions
Is SocialGTM a ReplyGuy alternative?
Yes. Both find posts worth answering and draft a reply. SocialGTM covers X, Reddit, Hacker News, Bluesky and LinkedIn, and gives more replies at the prices both tools sell.
How much cheaper is it per reply?
At the same price, SocialGTM gives more replies: 150 for $49 against 33 for $49, 400 for $99 against 100 for $99. That counts a ReplyGuy reply as 3 credits, the price its site gives for a reply posted and verified. A SocialGTM reply is a draft you approve, and you post it yourself except on Bluesky. SocialGTM counts every reply it writes, including ones you reject, and a LinkedIn reply counts as 3.
Whose Reddit account posts the reply?
With SocialGTM, yours: after you approve, the reply is copied and the thread opens, and you post it from your own account. ReplyGuy's FAQ says its Reddit replies go out from purchased accounts it emails to you after you subscribe, while its how-it-works page says Reddit replies are published manually.
Can I try it first?
ReplyGuy has a 3-day free trial. SocialGTM has no free plan; the smallest plan is $9 a month, month to month, with a hard monthly cap.
Create your agent and see for yourself. Also see SocialGTM vs Replymer.